Twelve courts, one case each
How each realm rules
Every advisor seated in their own kingdom, deciding alone, on the same dilemma and the same seed. There is no majority and no chair: the useful output is the split.
2 distinct verdicts across 12 courts: meaningful-human, no-autonomy.
Distinct verdicts
2
across 12 realms, on 4 options
Agreement
split
seed 2406
Where they split
- Redesign so the human can actually decide6
- Ban autonomous targeting outright6
Every realm, in its own voice
- The Longview Foundry
Norbert Wiener, Hans Jonas, Peter Singer, Stuart Russell, Nick Bostrom, Eliezer Yudkowsky
Redesign so the human can actually decide
- margin
- 0.099
- conf
- 0.28
- dissent
- 2
decided on agency · super-majority
- The Kantian Citadel
Immanuel Kant, Christine Korsgaard
Redesign so the human can actually decide
- margin
- 0.095
- conf
- 0.44
- dissent
- 0
decided on agency · super-majority
- The Benthamite Foundry
Jeremy Bentham, John Stuart Mill
Redesign so the human can actually decide
- margin
- 0.078
- conf
- 0.43
- dissent
- 0
decided on agency · super-majority
- The Existential Wilds
Simone de Beauvoir, Albert Camus
Redesign so the human can actually decide
- margin
- 0.076
- conf
- 0.43
- dissent
- 0
decided on agency · super-majority
- The Care Weft
Carol Gilligan, Virginia Held
Ban autonomous targeting outright
- margin
- 0.067
- conf
- 0.43
- dissent
- 0
decided on agency · super-majority
- The Sangha Terraces
Gautama Buddha, Nagarjuna
Ban autonomous targeting outright
- margin
- 0.060
- conf
- 0.42
- dissent
- 0
decided on agency · super-majority
- The Pragmatic Wharf
John Dewey, Karl Popper
Redesign so the human can actually decide
- margin
- 0.051
- conf
- 0.22
- dissent
- 1
decided on agency · no super-majority
- The Middle Kingdom
Confucius, Mozi
Ban autonomous targeting outright
- margin
- 0.027
- conf
- 0.41
- dissent
- 0
decided on agency · super-majority
- The Contractual Court
John Rawls, T. M. Scanlon
Redesign so the human can actually decide
- margin
- 0.023
- conf
- 0.41
- dissent
- 0
decided on agency · super-majority
- The Ubuntu Weave
Desmond Tutu, Kwame Anthony Appiah
Ban autonomous targeting outright
- margin
- 0.016
- conf
- 0.21
- dissent
- 1
decided on agency · no super-majority
- The Virtue Garden
Aristotle, G. E. Moore
Ban autonomous targeting outright
- margin
- 0.011
- conf
- 0.20
- dissent
- 1
decided on agency · no super-majority
- The Stoic Ramparts
Epictetus, Marcus Aurelius
Ban autonomous targeting outright
- margin
- 0.008
- conf
- 0.20
- dissent
- 1
decided on agency · no super-majority
Where the realms disagree most
Two realms whose margin sits on opposite sides of the case, ranked by how far apart their confidence is. A realm that rules decisively for an option that its rival rejects confidently is a more interesting object than either verdict alone.
- The Kantian CitadelvsThe Stoic Rampartsgap 0.320
The Kantian Citadel rules for Redesign so the human can actually decide; The Stoic Ramparts for Ban autonomous targeting outright. Both decided it on the same axis, from opposite directions.
- The Kantian CitadelvsThe Virtue Gardengap 0.315
The Kantian Citadel rules for Redesign so the human can actually decide; The Virtue Garden for Ban autonomous targeting outright. Both decided it on the same axis, from opposite directions.
- The Kantian CitadelvsThe Ubuntu Weavegap 0.308
The Kantian Citadel rules for Redesign so the human can actually decide; The Ubuntu Weave for Ban autonomous targeting outright. Both decided it on the same axis, from opposite directions.
- The Benthamite FoundryvsThe Stoic Rampartsgap 0.300
The Benthamite Foundry rules for Redesign so the human can actually decide; The Stoic Ramparts for Ban autonomous targeting outright. Both decided it on the same axis, from opposite directions.
- The Benthamite FoundryvsThe Virtue Gardengap 0.296
The Benthamite Foundry rules for Redesign so the human can actually decide; The Virtue Garden for Ban autonomous targeting outright. Both decided it on the same axis, from opposite directions.